There was no outright victor when Manchester United legend Bryan Robson faced HMRC in an IR35 tax dispute.
The case centred on the tax treatment of payments made to the former footballer’s personal services company, Bryan Robson Limited, relating to his ambassador role for Manchester United Football Club (MUFC). The contract with the club was worth £300,000 a year.
Robson’s company had launched an appeal against HMRC’s determination that the work Robson did through his contract with MUFC was subject to income tax and National Insurance under the off-payroll working rules (known as IR35).
The First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) has now released its ruling on the dispute. But, as we explain, the result was closer to a draw than a victory for either of the two teams on the pitch…
Background to the Bryan Robson Ltd v HMRC tax appeal
Robson is a former professional football player and manager who played for MUFC from 1981 to 1994 and for England from 1980 to 1991.
His personal services company, Bryan Robson Limited (BRL), was incorporated in June 1981. Robson and his wife, Denise Robson, are the sole directors and shareholders of the company.
Since its incorporation, Robson has generally used BRL to contract for his commercial work, i.e. his work other than as a football player or manager.
Robson has been an ambassador for MUFC for many years under a series of personal ambassador agreements, the first of which was in March 2008.
Tribunal Judge Tony Beare noted a peculiar feature of the agreements was they were executed by Robson personally and not by BRL, even though it was common ground Robson had generally used his company to contract for his commercial work.
The recognition the contracting party should have been BRL and not Robson himself led, in December 2019, to the agreement in place at that time being replaced with a new ambassador agreement between MUFC and BRL – and a new guarantee agreement between MUFC and Robson.
HMRC’s concessions
The case concerned whether the payments made under the contract between MUFC and BRL – for services provided by Robson – were subject to income tax and National Insurance contributions (NICs) as income from employment.
After BRL launched their appeal, HMRC conceded certain tax years shouldn’t be included in the case. The tax body accepted that because the agreements at that time had been entered into by Robson himself, and not by BRL, the legislation relating to intermediary personal service companies (IR35) didn’t apply.
Therefore, it was up to the FTT to decide on the appeals against HMRC’s income tax determinations and NICs decisions for the tax years ending April 2020 and April 2021. And, in the case of the first of those tax years, only to sums paid on or after 3 December 2019.
The issues: image rights and employment
It was common ground that, on and after 3 December 2019, there was no direct contract between MUFC and Robson, and that, instead, there was a contract between MUFC and BRL relating to Robson’s role as an ambassador for MUFC.
The disagreement at the heart of the case was how much of the consideration – which was payable under that contract – should be taxed under the IR35 legislation.
In broad terms, there were two areas of dispute in this context:
- Image rights issue
- Employment issue
The tribunal decision
The FTT ruled in favour of BRL on the image rights dispute but backed HMRC on the employment issue. The tribunal concluded:
- The payments weren’t subject to income tax and NICs to the extent they related to image rights granted under the actual contract.
- The hypothetical contract would have been a contract of employment and therefore the balance of the consideration was subject to income tax and NICs as income from employment.
Regarding the image rights, Judge Beare agreed with BRL that “consideration which can properly be said to have been paid for a licence of image rights as opposed to the personal performance of services is not subject to tax as employment income”.
Turning to the employment issue, the judge described Robson’s affiliation with MUFC as an “employment relationship, albeit one where the employee was given a measure of autonomy in the way in which the services were provided”.
He pointed out that Robson:
- Had very few, if any, engagements outside his engagement by the club
- Had a strong historic connection to the club
- Was required, under a hypothetical contract, to make personal appearances for the club and the sponsors as representative of the club
- Was required to make at least 35 personal appearances in each six–month period and to act in accordance with the directions of the club in making those personal appearances
Judge Beare told the two parties they must now decide how much extra tax and NICs Bryan Robson Ltd owed.
My thoughts on the Bryan Robson tax case
This dispute continues HMRC’s run on historic IR35 cases. It’s a clear example of how complex the application of the rules can be.
IR35 is a minefield that taxpayers should treat with caution. There’s no rule of thumb because each case is specific depending on its facts.
Although many of the issues have now been resolved given the recent changes in legislation, it’s likely to continue to be an area where HMRC will challenge taxpayers, especially high-profile cases. What’s more, there will no doubt continue to be mixed outcomes in these disputes.
The takeaway when it comes to setting up any planning that potentially involves the IR35 rules is: enter at your own peril.
IR35 tax advice
For expert advice on IR35, self-employment vs employment, or other tax matters, talk to our team on 01902 585 311 or email stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk
We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations. Plus, we offer a tax expert witness service for solicitors and forensic accountants.




