Gary Lineker’s long-running battle with HMRC over a reported £4.9m tax bill has been resolved, according to reports.
The ex-professional footballer turned sports broadcaster had been due to appear before a tax tribunal this month, but the final whistle has been blown after the case was settled out of court.
The dispute centred on whether the off-payroll working rules (known as IR35) applied to income received by Gary Lineker Media for Lineker’s services to the BBC and to BT Sport over a five-year period.
Background to the Gary Lineker tax battle
In March 2023, Lineker and his former wife Danielle Bux – together trading as Gary Lineker Media (GLM) – won their match against HMRC at the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT).
The case came to court in relation to Lineker’s services to the BBC and to BT Sport for the tax years 2013-14 to 2017-18 (inclusive).
Lineker and Bux had appealed against:
- Determinations issued by HMRC regarding income tax deductible via PAYE
- Notices issued by the tax authority in relation to Class 1 National Insurance contributions (NICs) for 2013-14 to 2017-18 (inclusive)
HMRC had argued the contracts – between Lineker and the BBC and Lineker and BT Sport – would have been contracts of employment.
The Gary Lineker Media partnership
The FTT tax appeal document shows that partnership accounts were drawn up in respect of each of the relevant tax years (with a year end of 31 July) and partnership returns filed. Those returns showed the turnover of GLM (income Lineker had received in return for services provided) and, following appropriate deductions, the net profit.
This net profit was divided between Lineker and Bux by allocating £30,000 to her and the balance to him.
Lineker filed a self-assessment tax return for each of the relevant tax years, 2013-14 to 2017-18, completing the partnership pages to account for the income received through GLM. For each tax year, Lineker accounted for income tax and Class 4 NICs on the entirety of the income from his services, less a fixed amount of £30,000, paid to Bux (and on which she paid tax).
The First-tier Tax Tribunal decision
Tribunal judge John Brooks explained that if a partnership applied IR35 to arrangements under which it supplied the personal services of one of its partners to a client, it would have to operate PAYE in respect of the deemed employment payment. And it could take a deduction when calculating its profits, with the effect that its profits were reduced. The partners don’t pay tax or Class 4 NICs on the deemed employment payment and there is therefore no double taxation.
The tribunal ruled that:
- The intermediaries legislation (IR35) can apply to arrangements where an individual’s services are supplied to a client through a partnership.
- GLM is a partnership.
- There were, as a matter of law, direct contracts between the BBC and Lineker (and Bux) and also BT Sport and Lineker (and Bux).
Judge John Brooks concluded that because of those direct contracts, IR35 didn’t – and couldn’t as a matter of law – apply.
Gary Lineker tax case settled
HMRC appealed the FTT decision, and the case was due to be heard at the Upper Tribunal this month.
But it’s now been reported the case is closed, with no further details released. An HMRC spokesperson has said: “We’ve settled this case with Gary Lineker Media. All settlements we reach are fully in line with our well-established framework for resolving tax disputes.”
My thoughts on the Gary Lineker tax dispute: take care with IR35 to avoid falling foul of HMRC
High-profile individuals are always an attractive target for HMRC as they have mass public appeal and are reported widely in the media.
In our experience, it’s far easier (and cheaper) to avoid long battles with HMRC.
Although there was a significant sum of money involved, the legal costs for both HMRC and the taxpayer (so in essence the taxpayer on both sides) can be eye-watering. We therefore assume both parties have found an application of the rules they can both live with to conclude matters and prevent further legal costs building up.
No doubt this will be a big relief to Lineker because prolonged HMRC enquiries can be emotionally and financially draining.
It’s a difficult balancing act to set up your affairs in the most tax-efficient way, while minimising the risk of long, intrusive HMRC enquiries.
IR35 is, and probably always will be, a huge bone of contention between taxpayers and HMRC and I’m sure there will be many more cases to come.
One thing is certain, IR35 planning is a minefield, so you should always get specialist advice you can trust.
Talk to a tax expert
For professional advice on IR35, self-employment vs employment, or other tax matters, talk to our team on 01902 585 311 or email stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk
We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations. Plus, we offer a tax expert witness service for solicitors and forensic accountants.




