Two entrepreneurs have lost their third appeal over a ‘round the world’ tax-planning scheme that sought to avoid capital gains tax on the disposal of their software businesses.

The Court of Appeal (CoA) backed HMRC and the decisions of two previous appeals in a case that centred on the meaning of ‘place of effective management’ (POEM) in a UK-Mauritius double taxation agreement.

The Haworth & Ors v HMRC appeal shines the spotlight on the risks of embarking on tax-planning arrangements that attempt to take advantage of double taxation treaties to escape tax.

Here, I examine the case and reveal what taxpayers and tax agents can learn from it…

Background to the Haworth & Ors v HMRC tax case

In early 2000, a family trust (GH Trust) created by Geoffrey Haworth held shares in TeleWare plc, while two family trusts (IFL Trust and S&A Trust), founded by Ian Lenagan, held shares in WorkPlace Group Ltd. Each of the three trusts had been set up more than a decade earlier and their trustees were all resident in Jersey.

A plan was developed to merge the software businesses – TeleWare and WorkPlace – and to list shares in the new company, TeleWork Group plc, on the London Stock Exchange.

The ‘round the world’ tax-planning scheme

In the spring of 2000, an adviser recommended the adoption of a ‘round the world’ tax-planning scheme that would avoid capital gains tax (CGT) if:

  1. The gains were realised at a time when the trusts had Mauritian trustees and
  2. UK trustees were appointed within the same tax year

The arrangement aimed to ensure the trusts were resident in Mauritius when the shares in TeleWork were disposed of but resident in the UK later in the same tax year. CGT would be avoided because Mauritius didn’t charge tax on such gains.

From Jersey to Mauritius

Deloitte & Touche Offshore Services Limited (DTOS) and Chandra Gujadhur, a director of DTOS, took the place of the Jersey trustees on the three trusts. Both DTOS and Mr Gujadhur were resident in Mauritius.

The merger of TeleWare and WorkPlace continued, and, by the end of July 2000, the trusts had all become shareholders in the new company, TeleWork.

TeleWork was floated on 3 August and the trusts disposed of most of their shares in the company. The Mauritius trustees resigned on 24 October 2000. And trustees resident in the UK – including the third appellant, now called SG Kleinwort Hambros Trust Company (UK) Ltd (SGKH) – were appointed instead.

The trusts were all resident in the UK for part of the 2000/2001 tax year. But it was common ground that, as a matter of Mauritian domestic law, the trusts were also resident in Mauritius during part of the year.

HMRC’s assessment and previous appeal decisions

HMRC amended the appellants’ tax returns for 2000-2001 and sought to charge CGT on Mr Haworth, Mr Lenagan and SGKH for the capital gains that arose from the disposals of the trusts’ shares in TeleWork.

Since then, the appellants have lost their appeals to the HMRC assessment at both the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) and the Upper Tribunal (UT).

They then went on to challenge the decisions in the Court of Appeal.

The POEM tax issue

The Court of Appeal case centred on the meaning of the ‘place of effective management’ (POEM) phrase used in the UK-Mauritius double taxation treaty.

The appellants argued that POEM should be determined in the same way as ‘residence’ for tax purposes, i.e. by reference to the location of ‘central management and control’ (CMC).

In contrast, HMRC contended the FTT didn’t err in the test it followed in determining the trusts’ POEM and said the appeal should be dismissed.

The Court of Appeal decision

In dismissing the appeal and backing HMRC, the Court of Appeal said construction of ‘place of effective management’ shouldn’t be approached in the same way as if the words appeared in domestic legislation.

The CoA said: “No international tribunal exists to rule on the interpretation of the term, but it nevertheless has an autonomous meaning and falls to be construed in a manner which is ‘international, not exclusively English’.”

The court also pointed out the concept of CMC wasn’t well-suited to perform the function of POEM and that POEM’s role as a tiebreaker was evident.

The CoA added that the role of the trustees in Mauritius was effectively pre-determined and that “‘effective’ or ‘realistic, positive’ management was elsewhere.”

The court concluded: “The Mauritius Trustees were (without impropriety) playing their parts in a script which had been written by others.”

My reaction to the ‘round the world’ tax appeal ruling

The Court of Appeal’s decision isn’t surprising, given the current tax landscape. When Mr Haworth and Mr Lenagan first implemented their planning, it was a very different landscape and there would have been a higher likelihood of such planning working.

Cases like this show how the world of tax planning has changed in a relatively short time.

My advice for taxpayers and tax agents

We’d never encourage taxpayers to carry out this type of planning today. The tax world is very much built around substance over form now, so your company’s accounts need to show what it’s actually earned in a particular period. Gone are the days when the strict letter of the law applied.

It is still possible to carry out planning to minimise capital gains tax on the sale of shares using non-residency status. But using ‘shortcuts’ that allow you to stay in the UK or return shortly after the sale won’t work now because of the anti-avoidance rules.

So, if you’re thinking about leaving the UK to mitigate tax, it’s essential to first get professional advice before making any decision on what action to take.

UK tax planning advice

Our trusted tax planning professionals will help ensure you structure your tax affairs in the best way, so you can make the most of your money and assets without falling foul of HMRC.

We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations, and we offer a tax expert witness service.

Contact our team today on 01902 585311 or stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation