A couple have lost their dispute with HMRC over their claim for £1.8m Entrepreneurs’ Relief on the sale of their shares in a London boatyard.

However, Andrew and Charlotte Moffat have won their appeal against the tax body’s decision to charge them more than £370k in fines for failing to take reasonable care in their tax returns.

Here, I take a close look at the case and consider what taxpayers, accountants and other tax agents can learn from it.

Background to the Andrew & Charlotte Moffat v HMRC tax appeal

Chelsea Yacht and Boat Company Ltd (CYBC) at Cheyne Pier, Chelsea, primarily provides moorings on the River Thames, together with services and maintenance, and also offers boat repairs and renovation.

Andrew and Charlotte Moffat launched their tax appeal after HMRC denied their claims for Entrepreneurs’ Relief (ER) totalling almost £1.8 million on the sale of their £17.8 million shareholding in CYBC.

The couple also appealed against the tax body’s decision to charge them more than £370,000 in penalties for failing to take reasonable care in their 2016-2017 tax returns, which contained the ER claims.

The issues to be decided by the court

The First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) considered the following:

  1. Should HMRC have issued its Notices of Enquiry and Closure Notices?
  2. Was CYBC a trading company for the purpose of ER for the 12 months leading up to the share disposal on 30 September 2016? In other words, was there a substantial amount of non-trading activities taking place?
  3. Were the inaccuracies in the Moffats’ tax returns caused by their careless behaviour?

The FTT noted it was common ground HMRC was correct to issue its Notices of Enquiry and Closure Notices. So, the tribunal focused on the second and third issues.

It said it was up to the Moffats to prove the amendments made by the Closure Notice were wrong and, in particular, that the ER claim was valid and accurate.

But it was for HMRC to show the penalty notices were validly issued and that Mr and Mrs Moffat’s behaviour was careless in filing inaccurate self-assessment tax returns.

HMRC’s argument

HMRC refused the ER claim because it said CYBC wasn’t a trading company and, by extension, Chelsea Marine Ltd (CML), wasn’t the holding company of a trading group.

Other facts about the case

For context:

  • Mr and Mrs Moffat have been directors of Thames River Moorings Ltd (TRM) since its incorporation in 2011
  • The couple incorporated CML in July 2015
  • They became directors of CYBC in February 2016
  • CML was sold to TRM for £17.8m in September 2016 – and this is the disposal the Moffats claimed ER on

Regarding the penalties, HMRC said the penalties were due because the couple had acted carelessly when making their returns, which contained errors.

The tax body said: “A taxpayer taking reasonable care would have taken steps to ensure they were fully aware of all the conditions for claiming Entrepreneurs’ Relief and that the shares disposed of qualified.”

Mr and Mrs Moffat’s view

The Moffats insisted CYBC’s activities didn’t, to a “substantial extent”, include activities other than trading activities in the 12 months before the sale of the shares in CML in September 2016. They therefore felt they were right to claim ER.

The tribunal’s decision on the Entrepreneurs’ Relief claim

The FTT ruled CYBC’s activities included substantial non-trading activities because its main source of income at that time was from mooring fees and licences, which was income from exploiting a proprietary interest in land.

The tribunal added that the “income derived from the exercise of property rights so called by the owner of land (freehold or leasehold) is not income derived from the carrying on of a trade” (according to the Griffiths (Inspector of Taxes) v Jackson [1983] case).

The tribunal therefore dismissed the Moffats’ appeal in relation to ER.

The carelessness issue

The FTT said Mr Moffat had obtained advice orally from professional and competent advisers and that it wasn’t unreasonable to have done so.

The tribunal ruled the couple took reasonable care to avoid inaccuracy in their tax returns and weren’t careless, and so their appeals against the penalties were allowed.

My reaction to the Andrew & Charlotte Moffat v HMRC appeal ruling

The old ER cases are a good guide to how to apply the current BADR rules (Entrepreneurs’ Relief has been renamed Business Asset Disposal Relief).

Given the facts in the Moffats’ appeal, I’m not surprised the tribunal ruled there was a substantial level of non-trading activity.

But what is interesting (and important) is the judges didn’t allow the fines on the basis the taxpayer had taken professional advice. There are many ‘grey’ areas of tax where a tax adviser might make a different interpretation to HMRC.

Ultimately, the courts will decide which interpretation they lean towards. However, the result of this appeal is useful to show that just because the interpretation isn’t the chosen view, it doesn’t mean the taxpayer acted carelessly.

The fact is our tax legislation is complex and, in many areas, extremely vague, so there will inevitably be differences in interpretation. What is important is that a taxpayer can show they took advice and acted on it, rather than they made a claim and hoped for the best!

UK tax relief advice

For expert advice on Business Asset Disposal Relief or other tax matters, talk to our team on 01902 585311 or stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk

We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations. Plus, we offer a tax expert witness service for solicitors and forensic accountants.

Contact us today

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation