Tax disputes about Business Asset Disposal Relief always catch my eye, such as the Cox v HMRC appeal.

The case may have been decided a few months ago but it’s one that taxpayers and tax agents can learn from. It centres on fines of more than £32k for “carelessness” and the issue of how the rules for suspension of penalties should be interpreted.

Here, I examine the dispute and share my thoughts and reaction.

Background to the Cox v HMRC tax appeal

Philip Cox (PC) and his wife Debra Cox (DC), together referred to as ‘PDC’, appealed against a penalty notice of more than £16,000 each, issued by HMRC for the tax year 2019-20.

More specifically, PDC:

  • Sought confirmation their appeal should be treated as having been notified within the “post-review period”.
  • Appealed against the penalties for inaccuracy/failing to take reasonable care when submitting their tax returns in relation to a claim for Entrepreneurs’ Relief (now renamed Business Asset Disposal Relief).
  • Appealed against the refusal of HMRC to suspend the penalties.

In 2018, Philip and Debra Cox, Ian Lowe (IL) and his wife, and Nick Beal (NB) and his wife (all collectively the ‘outgoing shareholders’) decided to dispose of their shareholdings in David Williams IFA Holdings Ltd (DWIFA) to David Sparrow (DS) and his wife and to Stephen Womack (SW) and his wife (all collectively the ‘continuing shareholders’). The outgoing shareholders were all paid in cash. NB, PC, IL, DS and SW were directors of DWIFA (the ‘IFA directors’).

The outgoing shareholders agreed informally that DS and NB would act as the points of contact for them, including liaising with solicitors, and keeping them informed.

The firm of solicitors used was EWM Solicitors (EWM) and the partner involved was Ian Morris (IM), assisted by Lisa Stevenson (LS), a tax specialist and senior associate of EWM.

The BADR/ER issue

The inaccuracy in the return, which was the subject of the appeal, was a claim for Entrepreneurs’ Relief/Business Asset Disposal Relief (ER/BADR) that failed because a basic condition to obtain relief, a 5% shareholding, wasn’t met. The amount of tax that was then due, based on a corrected amount of disposal proceeds received by PDC, was around £215,000.

The evidence presented at the appeal included a meeting that took place on 18 April 2019 with all the IFA directors present and IM and LS. LS went “round the table” and, in relation to PC, IL and NB, confirmed the disposal of their entire shareholdings and those of their wives would qualify for ER as they satisfied the ER conditions. In evidence, DS stated this required confirmation that PC, IL, DS and NB, and their spouses, owned their shares for the relevant period of time, that the shares in the company related to a qualifying company for ER and that they had enough shares.

On 30 April 2019, PC and DC gifted shares to other shareholders of DWIFA, taking PDC’s total percentage ownership of DWIFA to below 5% each. Then, on 20 May 2019, PDC disposed of their remaining shares, and subsequently claimed for ER in their 2019-20 tax returns.

After HMRC issued Notices of Enquiry to PDC to investigate the capital gains tax reliefs on the 2019-20 tax returns, PDC conceded the claim made for BADR was invalid and expressed their wish to withdraw the claim for ER.

But HMRC went on to issue closure notices for the tax PDC owed and the penalty for “carelessness”.

The tribunal decision

PDC appealed to the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT), who said it was up to HMRC to show the inaccuracy in PDC’s return was most likely due to a failure to take reasonable care.

And, after considering the arguments, Judge Ruthven Gemmell said: “The carelessness was PDC’s not taking professional advice after having been told that they qualify for ER and then changing their shareholdings. PDC did not re-examine that advice in the light of the changed events. They completed their tax returns based on previous advice based on different facts.”

The tribunal said HMRC was therefore right to issue the penalty notice.

The FTT also backed the tax body’s decision not to suspend the penalties. It said the conditions put forward by PDC were “no more than a basic requirement and the decision to preclude suspension was justified and not flawed on those grounds”.

The judge added: “The tribunal did not consider that HMRC had adopted a rigid approach and, therefore, decided that PDC’s inaccuracy was a ‘one off’ event and automatically precluded suspension.”

The FTT dismissed PDC’s appeal and refused their application for costs.

My reaction to the Cox v HMRC tax appeal decision

This case demonstrates how taxpayers might seek tax advice in anticipation of a transaction without fully understanding the intricacies of the advice given. As the transaction progresses, changes may occur in their personal circumstances that in turn impact on the original advice they received. So, to be able to rely on any advice given, it’s important to revisit that guidance and ensure nothing has changed, otherwise the outcome they were expecting may not be the one they achieve.

Revisiting previous advice might seem like an extra cost the taxpayer would rather avoid. But it’s crucial to be aware of the potential impact of changes in their personal circumstances and/or legislation.

Mistakes of this kind can be extremely costly for the taxpayer. They might agree a deal based on their net cash position after tax, so having to pay extra tax (plus interest and penalties) will greatly reduce that net cash position. Therefore, when carrying out any deal, it’s false economy for a taxpayer to cut back on tax advice when this could leave them with a much-reduced cash pot.

My thoughts on the penalty suspension issue

The suspension rules focus on both the taxpayer and HMRC jointly setting criteria to ensure an inaccuracy doesn’t happen again. This can be very difficult where the transaction relates to a large one-off event, such as the sale of shares in a business.

So, taxpayers should bear in mind they don’t have an automatic right to apply the suspension rules in all circumstances.

This again shows why it’s vital to re-examine tax advice after a transaction has been agreed and the final position is known.

Trusted tax advice for businesses and individuals

For expert advice on Business Asset Disposal Relief or other tax matters, talk to our team on 01902 585 311 or email stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk

We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations. Plus, we offer a tax expert witness service for solicitors and forensic accountants.

Contact us today

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation