A couple have won their £3.3 million tax case after showing a court the Chelsea house they owned was their principal private residence. One of the reasons for their victory was the husband moving his 2,000-bottle wine collection into a “bespoke” wine cellar at the multi-million-pound residence.

The Raymond and Diana Eyre v HMRC [2025] TC09498 tax appeal is an intriguing case. It illustrates the importance of whether you can demonstrate ‘personalisation’ of a property when claiming principal private residence (PPR) relief.

The Eyres’ customisation of their house – which they sold for £27 million in 2014 – even included a monogrammed cigar humidor (what every home needs!).

Here, I dissect the case and share my reaction and thoughts on what it means for taxpayers and tax agents.

Background to the Raymond and Diana Eyre v HMRC tax appeal

At all relevant times, Mr and Mrs Eyre owned a house in Holland Park, London.

In September 2010, the Eyres bought another house in Burnsall Street, Chelsea for £9.75m. They demolished that property and built a new house on the same site, which they sold for £27,150,000.

The couple submitted their self-assessment tax returns on the basis that Burnsall Street had been their principal private residence (PPR).

But HMRC took a different view, deciding the purchase, redevelopment and sale was an “adventure in the nature of a trade” and the property wasn’t their principal residence.

The tax body issued the Eyres with individual income tax assessments. Mr Eyre’s was to the tune of £1.76m, while Mrs Eyre’s totalled £1.57m.

The couple appealed and the case was heard by the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT).

The ‘venture in the nature of a trade’ issue

The Income Tax Act 2007 states that ‘trade’ includes any ‘venture in the nature of trade’.

HMRC accepted the Eyres hadn’t become involved in any other property trading transactions. But they decided the purchase and sale of Burnsall Street was a venture in the nature of trade because the couple’s intention in buying and developing Burnsall Street was to “realise a profit from the property”.

The tribunal disagreed with HMRC and backed the Eyres on this issue. The FTT found that in May 2010 the Eyres intended to refurbish Burnsall Street, move into that house as their home, and sell the Holland Park house.

Personalisation, time and energy

The tribunal agreed with the Eyres’ barrister’s argument that the extent to which the couple personalised Burnsall Street and the amount of time they spent in making it suit their needs was entirely inconsistent with an intention to buy, develop and sell at a profit.

Here, the FTT drew attention to its findings of fact about the involvement of the couple in the development, including:

  • The wine cellar was designed for Mr Eyre’s extensive wine collection
  • Mr Eyre and his personal trainer chose the gym equipment
  • The car charger in the garage only worked with the model of electric car Mr Eyre had bought
  • The artwork was commissioned
  • The children decided on the décor for their rooms
  • Mrs Eyre worked with an Italian designer to create the garden

The continued ownership of the Holland Park house

HMRC relied on the fact the Eyres didn’t in fact sell the Holland Park property. However, the FTT concluded this house had been on the market since 2010 – other than during the period when the basement and related works were being carried out – and that viewings did take place during that time.

The capital gains tax and PPR issue

This issue centred on whether Burnsall Street was the Eyres’ main residence and, therefore, whether they were entitled to principal private residence relief.

The FTT backed the couple’s barrister in his view the Eyres had proved the degree of permanence and continuity sufficient to turn “mere occupation into residence”.

The tribunal found that, from 9 July 2013, when the Eyres moved into Burnsall Street, until they moved out in February 2014, the property was their “residence” within the meaning of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act.

And although they had more than one residence during that time, they nominated Burnsall Street for capital gains tax (CGT) purposes from 13 July 2013. So, the FTT ruled, Burnsall Street was their main residence from that date until they moved out, and they are entitled to PPR.

My reaction to the principal private residence tax case ruling

PPR relief remains one of the more valuable capital gains tax reliefs. But the Eyres’ case is another illustration of the complexity involved in determining what is a ‘residence’ for the purposes of the relief, especially when a homeowner has more than one home. There’s a huge amount of case law around when someone is or isn’t entitled to it.

Many of the cases delve into minute detail in terms of how a house has been used and how a taxpayer can prove it was their main dwelling. The Eyres’ tax appeal is a further example of taxpayers needing to provide a clear audit trail of why they made a claim and why they believed a gain was tax-free.

What can taxpayers and tax agents learn from the Eyres’ tax appeal?

You shouldn’t simply assume that owning and living in a house means any gain is tax-free.

If HMRC takes issue with the application of PPR relief, you’ll need a robust paper trail to back your case. This might require detailed conversations between a taxpayer and their tax adviser about the use of that home versus usage of any other homes they may own, and discussions around what evidence they have.

Although the relief is automatic for people selling their main home, there are many pitfalls that can cause problems for taxpayers, so it’s vital to fully explore the risks before applying the relief.

Principal private residence relief tax advice

For expert advice on PPR relief and other tax issues, contact Churchill Taxation here.

Our team can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations, and we offer a tax expert witness service.

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation