A woman who faced a £3.1 million tax bill after overstaying her time in the UK to care for her twin sister and her children has won her case at the Court of Appeal.
The decision is the latest twist in the saga that dates from 2020 when HMRC challenged the woman’s tax return for the 2015/2016 tax year. The tax body had argued her overstay in the UK didn’t amount to ‘exceptional circumstances’ under the Statutory Residence Test and that she owed tax on £8 million of dividends.
The Court of Appeal ruling reinstates the original First-tier Tax Tribunal decision and overturns the Upper Tribunal judgement.
Background to the A Taxpayer v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 106 tax appeal
The appeal centred on whether the anonymous taxpayer was resident in the UK in the tax year ending 5 April 2016.
She claimed she wasn’t liable for UK income tax on the large dividend she received that year as she was resident in the Republic of Ireland.
The Court of Appeal was told this was the first (and so far, only) case in which the Statutory Residence Test (SRT) had been considered.
The 45-day rule – and the exceptional circumstances argument
In 2015/16, the woman was in the UK at the end of the day on 50 days – when the limit was 45 days under the SRT rules for her circumstances.
The woman argued six of those days should be disregarded because of the ‘exceptional circumstances’ exemption. She maintained she was compelled to stay in the UK to help her sister who was suffering from alcoholism, was suicidal and was failing to look after her own children.
But HMRC disagreed that these amounted to exceptional circumstances, or that she’d been prevented from leaving the UK, and issued a closure notice amending her tax return to include the dividend.
The woman appealed to the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) and won her case, with the tribunal finding there were exceptional circumstances on each of the six days in question.
HMRC then appealed to the Upper Tribunal (UT), who set aside the FTT’s decision and remade it in the tax authority’s favour.
The Statutory Residence Test
The woman took her case to the Court of Appeal, who focused on interpreting the wording of the Statutory Residence Test. So, to meet the exemption, the following conditions must be met:
- The circumstances are exceptional.
- The circumstances are beyond the person’s control.
- The person would not be present in the UK at the end of the day but for those circumstances.
- The circumstances prevent the person from leaving the UK.
- The person intends to leave the UK as soon as those circumstances permit.
It’s worth noting that conditions 3 and 5 weren’t disputed because these were considered satisfied, while condition 2 wasn’t central to the argument.
The main thrust of the case focused on whether conditions 1 and 4 had been met. So, were the circumstances exceptional and did they prevent the woman from leaving the UK?
The Court of Appeal decision
Lord Justice Nugee – backed by Lady Justice Falk and Lord Justice Males – found the UT was wrong to rule the FTT made a mistake in saying moral inhibitions couldn’t be what prevented the woman from leaving the UK.
And, on the subject of whether moral obligations could be part of the exceptional circumstances, Nugee LJ said: “In my judgement therefore the moral or societal obligations which the illness of a relative – or any other situation – imposes on [an individual] form part of the overall circumstances, and can and should be taken account of in considering whether the circumstances as a whole qualify as exceptional.”
The judge drew attention to the FTT findings that:
- The immediate need to establish a stable household in which the minor children could be cared for was an exceptional circumstance that was outside the woman’s control.
- She wouldn’t have been in the UK at the end of each day relevant to the appeal but for the fact that she needed to care for both her twin sister and her minor children.
- This need prevented her from leaving the UK until such time as she had stabilised the situation.
- She intended to leave the UK as soon as such circumstances permitted.
- The circumstances were beyond her control.
Exceptional circumstances remained valid for each relevant day
The FTT also accepted that if the reason for the woman staying in the UK was the same each day and if that reason constituted exceptional circumstances, then that reason remained valid for each relevant day.
After considering the above, the Court of Appeal found there was sufficient material before them to conclude the woman intended to leave as soon as circumstances permitted, and that the need for her to stay continued until she left on each occasion.
Nugee LJ explained: “That may have been a generous conclusion in her favour, but the assessment of whether the circumstances prevented her leaving on each of the days in question, and whether each of the other statutory conditions was fulfilled on each day, was a matter for them, and I do not consider the UT was justified in concluding that they had no material on which to reach conclusions in her favour.”
The Court of Appeal allowed the woman’s appeal and restored the FTT’s decision.
My reaction to the Court of Appeal ruling
This is a welcome decision for taxpayers. But it shows how complex and subjective many of our tax rules are, when different courts can interpret a concept such as exceptional circumstances so differently. And we may not be at the end of the road yet with this case.
These conflicting decisions add to the uncertainty for taxpayers and those who work in the field of tax. The only way to have certainty is to avoid finding yourself in exceptional circumstances territory, which by its very nature might be impossible.
My advice for taxpayers: do you fit HMRC’s criteria?
The Court of Appeal has taken a common-sense approach in their interpretation of exceptional circumstances. But the case demonstrates how difficult it can be to convince HMRC that exceptional circumstances apply to a case.
Where possible, you shouldn’t rely on the exceptional circumstances rule unless you clearly fit HMRC’s criteria.
My advice for tax agents: tread carefully with exceptional circumstances
When completing a tax return, be cautious if your client says they spent X amount of ‘exceptional’ days in the UK.
Given how difficult it is to satisfy HMRC that exceptional days exist, you should ask your client for further information and discuss the criteria with them. So, if HMRC opens an enquiry, your client is forewarned and hopefully prepared.
Exceptional circumstances tax advice
If you need advice on the Statutory Residence Test or exceptional circumstances, get in touch with our team of tax specialists.
We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations, and we offer a tax expert witness service.




