A judge has blamed “misunderstandings on both sides” for a tax dispute about an offshore employee benefit trust (EBT).

Allan Jack has lost his appeal against HMRC’s closure notice that money transferred by Mr Jack’s employer to an EBT was employment income and subject to income tax. HMRC said the employment income in Mr Jack’s 2010-2011 tax return had been understated by around £48,000.

But Mr Jack argued the taxable amount for that year should be £24,554 because the money received after 9 December 2010 should be outside the scope of the loan charge.

The First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) has backed HMRC, ruling the loan charge provisions didn’t apply and that the money transferred to the EBT was taxable as Mr Jack’s employment earnings.

Here, I look at the background to the case, the decision, and what taxpayers and tax agents can learn from it.

The Allan Jack v HMRC tax dispute 

Mr Jack was employed by Aston Management Limited (AML), an employer based outside the UK in the Isle of Man. As an employee of AML, he was also a beneficiary of an EBT, which had an Isle of Man trustee. Mr Jack was resident in, and worked in, the UK throughout the relevant tax year.

Mr Jack – who represented himself at the tribunal – didn’t dispute he’d taken part in a disguised remuneration scheme in that tax year. (For the avoidance of doubt, no penalties were charged in connection with the closure notice and no criticism was made of Mr Jack’s participation in the scheme.)

How the scheme worked:

  • Mr Jack’s services were supplied by AML to end clients, who would pay AML for those services.
  • After the deduction of administration fees, the amount paid by the end client would be paid out by AML in two ways: part was paid as a basic salary to Mr Jack and the balance was paid to an EBT.
  • The EBT then paid benefits (in the form of loans) to Mr Jack from the money contributed by AML. That is, both the salary to Mr Jack and the balance paid to the EBT were paid by AML because of Mr Jack’s work as an employee of AML.

Common ground in the employee benefit trust case

There was no dispute between the parties that:

  • £48,034 had been advanced to Mr Jack during the relevant tax year.
  • He’d repaid £23,479 of the loans on 21 April 2011.
  • The arrangements were ultimately ineffective for UK tax purposes.
  • The closure notice was valid.

The arguments

Mr Jack argued the loan charge review had concluded loans made on or after 9 December 2010 – that had been repaid before 5 April 2019 – wouldn’t be within the scope of the loan charge.

But HMRC said tax was due on the money transferred from AML to the EBT, which was redirected employment income of Mr Jack.

HMRC admitted, however, that references to 9 December 2010 in correspondence came about because it had misunderstood the P11D submitted by AML. It thought it applied only to the period up to that date, and not that it considered the loan charge applied in this context.

The tribunal decision 

The FTT judge, Anne Fairpo, observed: “This appeal unfortunately arises from misunderstandings on both sides, not assisted by the changes in case law and legislation over the years relating to employment remuneration arrangements including schemes such as that operated by AML.”

She said the closure notice was clear it was charging income tax under the employment income provisions on the transfers from AML to the EBT and not on the loans to Mr Jack. So, the loan charge provisions weren’t relevant to this charge.

And because Mr Jack didn’t dispute the payment by AML to the EBT was redirected earnings and agreed the amount of the loans made to him was equivalent to the amount transferred from AML to the EBT in the 2010-11 tax year, he wasn’t overcharged tax.

Mr Jack’s appeal was therefore rejected.

My thoughts on the EBT case

The curse of employee benefit trusts seems destined to never be broken.

I’m not surprised there are disputes still going on. That’s because we’ve seen many changes over the years and there are complexities involved in what are now the disguised remuneration rules.

The tribunal decision isn’t unexpected. EBTs is an area where HMRC has tightened up in the extreme, and I’m sure this won’t be the last of such wrangles.

Trusted UK tax advice

For professional advice on employee benefit trusts and other tax issues, talk to our team on 01902 585311 or stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk

We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations, and we offer a tax expert witness service for solicitors and forensic accountants.

Contact us

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation