Investors have been caught out by the transactions in securities anti-avoidance rules.

The First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) has refused the entrepreneurs’ attempts to claim Enterprise Investment Scheme disposal relief from capital gains tax on share buybacks.

In Osmond and Allen v HMRC, the FTT ruled in favour of the tax body, concluding the main purpose of the taxpayers’ claim was to avoid income tax.

Background to the Osmond and Allen v HMRC tax appeal

Hugh Osmond and Matthew Allen are serial entrepreneurs who have made successive investments, both independently and together, over more than 30 years with a view to realising capital gains.

Osmond and Allen each invested in Xercise Ltd as minority shareholders through making three successive share subscriptions in accordance with the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) between February 1996 and May 1998.

Xercise Ltd was originally incorporated in 1995 to operate Broadlands Sports Club in Great Yarmouth, Norfolk. The business, as operated by Xercise Ltd, wasn’t profitable and the entire business was sold in September 2002.

Mindful of the capital gains tax (CGT) exemption that attached to their shareholdings in Xercise Ltd, Osmond and Allen prevailed on the other shareholders not to dissolve the company but to implement a time-consuming and elaborate purchase of own shares by Xercise Ltd out of capital. This was completed in March 2003, leaving Osmond and Allen as the only members of Xercise Ltd.

But by the end of 2009, the members of Xercise Ltd comprised a disparate group of 17 investors. However, it was only Osmond and Allen who had the benefit of the ongoing EIS exemption.

Xercise Ltd was voluntarily liquidated and a new holding company was created, Xercise2 Ltd.

In March 2015, Osmond and Allen received £11 million and £9 million for share buybacks and claimed EIS disposal relief on the £20 million total.

Osmond and Allen’s view on their share buybacks and EIS relief

Osmond, Allen and their advisers said the share buybacks represented a return of capital and was therefore subject to the CGT regime. However, no CGT was payable because they benefited from a complete exemption through EIS disposal relief.

HMRC’s argument

HMRC took an opposing view. They said the transactions in securities (TIS) regime applied and the consideration was subject to income tax and not CGT.

In March 2021, HMRC issued counteraction notices and assessments in relation to the 2014/2015 tax year. They said the taxpayers owed income tax of around £6 million (£3,293,936 and £2,749,999).

Both Osmond and Allen appealed against the assessments.

Main purpose issue

The FTT said the question of whether Osmond and Allen had a main purpose of obtaining an income tax advantage was a “pure question of subjective fact”. It added that it was a purpose and not a benefit test, and concerned only an income tax advantage and not a more general tax advantage. The test would be satisfied if one of the main purposes of the transactions was to obtain an income tax advantage.

The tribunal said Osmond and Allen were concerned a change of government would affect the availability of EIS disposal relief in their circumstances.

The FTT found the taxpayers’ main purpose for the share buybacks was to enable them to crystallise or bank the EIS relief. It therefore followed that a main purpose was also to get an income tax advantage.

The tribunal concluded that, as a matter of law, Osmond and Allen’s main purpose of entering into the share buyback was to obtain an income tax advantage.

Relevant consideration issue

The FTT said the share buybacks fell within the transactions in securities regime. It said it would therefore be “illogical” if having brought such buybacks into the net of the TIS regime, they couldn’t be challenged if the consideration was provided by way of a return of share capital.

The judge said: “The net of the TIS regime is intended to be very wide and applies where consideration is paid in capital form in circumstances where it would not otherwise be subject to income tax.”

Counteraction notice issue

The FTT ruled that the objective reader principle validated the counteraction notices and so found for HMRC on the counteraction notice issue.

Limitation period issue

The tribunal concluded that the TIS regime provided HMRC with a power to issue a counteraction notice and a corresponding assessment within six years from the end of the relevant tax year.

The judge said: “In the circumstances of this appeal, where the assessments were made within six years of the relevant tax year, it is our further conclusion that they were valid in time assessments.”

The FTT dismissed the taxpayers’ appeals.

My thoughts on the EIS disposal relief tax appeal

Some aspects of this case are surprising. However, it’s also a useful demonstration of the far-reaching anti-avoidance legislation HMRC has in its armoury.

It can be easy for us all to sometimes forget the tax body has many areas of anti-avoidance legislation it can apply if it considers transactions were put in place primarily to gain a tax advantage. And transactions in securities legislation is one such area.

We often talk about TIS legislation and it’s good practice to obtain clearance from HMRC ahead of any transaction that could be caught out by the rules.

Trusted UK tax advice

Our team of experienced tax advisers will help you make sense of complex tax rules. We can also help with HMRC tax enquiries and investigations. Plus, we offer a tax expert witness service.

Call us today on 01902 585 311 or email stephanie.churchill@churchilltaxation.co.uk

Or you can book a 1:1 Tax Power Hour with one of our expert team – click here to book.

Steph Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing director & co-owner of Churchill Taxation