The twists and turns in the world of tax continue with Angela Rayner’s resignation from government in the wake of the stamp duty storm.
Ms Rayner has stepped down as Deputy Prime Minister, housing secretary and deputy leader of the Labour Party after failing to pay enough tax on her £800,000 flat in Hove, East Sussex.
Her resignation came as the Prime Minister’s ethics adviser Sir Laurie Magnus said Ms Rayner had “acted with integrity” but concluded she had breached the Ministerial Code.
Here, I look at the ethics adviser’s findings and explain why specialist tax advice could have changed the course of events.
Background to the Stamp Duty Land Tax controversy
The row erupted after it was reported Ms Rayner had saved £40,000 in tax on the Hove flat. She was said to have paid £30,000 of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) instead of the higher rate of £70,000 reserved for additional home purchases.
Ms Rayner said she had paid the standard rate of stamp duty when buying the seaside flat in May, after receiving legal advice. Earlier in the year, she had sold her remaining interest in the family home in Ashton-under-Lyne, Greater Manchester, to her son’s trust.
As the storm intensified, the MP said she had “sought further advice from a leading tax counsel”. She also referred herself to Sir Laurie – the independent adviser on ministerial standards – whose findings were released on Friday. And she said she was working with HMRC to resolve the matter and pay what was due.
Sir Laurie’s investigation
Sir Laurie explained that after Ms Rayner sold her 25% share in the family home in Ashton-under-Lyne, she ceased to own any part of that property.
But he pointed out that, under the relevant legislation, a person who doesn’t own a property can nonetheless be deemed to hold an interest in it if certain circumstances apply. These include where that property is held by a trust, and the beneficiary of the trust is a child of that person under the age of 18. He added that he understood there were extra complexities, for example concerning the type of trust in question and the reason for which the trust was established.
As part of his probe, Sir Laurie reviewed the advice Ms Rayner received at the time from the legal firms involved and the associated documentation that was prepared for her to make the purchase.
He said: “This advice gave rise to Ms Rayner’s understanding – which I consider to have been held in good faith – that the lower rate of SDLT was applicable when purchasing the property in Hove.”
Sir Laurie concluded:
- Ms Rayner was open about the existence of the trust and considered that, between them, the firms advising her had appropriate knowledge and awareness of the details and circumstances of the trust.
- On the basis of the advice she received, Ms Rayner believed the lower rate of SDLT would be applicable. Indeed, she was twice informed in writing that this was the case.
- But in those two instances, that advice was qualified by the acknowledgement that it didn’t constitute expert tax advice and was accompanied by a suggestion, or in one case a recommendation, that specific tax advice be obtained.
- And if such expert tax advice had been received, as it later was, it would likely have advised her that a higher rate of SDLT was payable.
My thoughts on the fallout from the Angela Rayner stamp duty storm
Sir Laurie’s comments show why taxpayers should get specialist tax advice if their circumstances are out of the ordinary.
Ultimately, the buck stops with the taxpayer to report to HMRC and pay their taxes, and, in Ms Rayner’s case, to abide by the Ministerial Code.
SDLT and trust tax are both specialist areas of taxation, and anyone who doesn’t specialise in these areas should always recommend getting specialist advice. And although taxpayers may view paying for this specific advice as an ‘unnecessary cost’, they’re recommended to do so because of the complexities of our tax system.
If Ms Rayner had obtained the right advice, she could have avoided the crisis that engulfed her political career and the government.




