No sooner had I finished digesting the Spending Review 2025 than the government released another document for me to peruse: its Tax Policy Making Principles paper.
And now (they say things comes in threes) the UK tax gap figures have been released.
So, I thought I’d combine all three of these talking points into one neat blog – and add my reaction and thoughts on each topic.
But the big question on everyone’s lips: are tax rises looking more likely than ever at the Autumn Budget 2025?
Spending Review 2025
The Spending Review 2025 (SR25) – published on 11 June – sets departmental budgets for day-to-day spending until 2028-29 and establishes investment budgets until the end of the decade.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ spending pledges include:
- Health: annual NHS day-to-day spending to reach £226 billion by 2028-29, equivalent to a 3% average annual real-terms growth rate over the next three years.
- Defence: defence spending to rise to 2.6% of GDP from 2027, with an ambition to reach 3% in the next Parliament.
- Education: the core schools budget to increase from £64.8 billion to £69.5 billion in cash terms by the end of the review period.
- HMRC: a further £500 million to be invested in HMRC’s digital services over the review period. The government wants a minimum of 90% of customer interactions to be digital self-serve by 2029-30, up from around 70% in 2025. The aim is to “improve services so people can easily and quickly get the information they need without having to call or write to HMRC.” However, the government vowed to continue to ensure alternative channels, including phonelines, were still there for those who needed them.
- Tackling the tax gap: £1.7 billion to be provided over four years to fund an extra 5,500 compliance and 2,400 debt management staff to ensure more of the tax due is paid.
Reacting to the Spending Review announcements, Paul Johnson, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), acknowledged the Chancellor had “some incredibly tough decisions to take and balancing acts to perform.”
But he added that with Ms Reeves staying within her fiscal rules by a “gnat’s whisker”, any move in the wrong direction would “almost certainly spark more tax rises.”
My thoughts on the Spending Review
Basic maths means big spending decisions must be paid for. Given the current levels of borrowing, it seems inconceivable that none of the spending will be paid for by tax rises. Whether those rises are transparent or by way of ‘stealth tax’ remains to be seen.
It’s a tough job balancing the books and we’ll see if any further ‘difficult’ decisions must be made that result in more tax hikes. And let’s not forget that even with increased investment, HMRC has a hard job trying to service the various areas of tax effectively. Plus, a change in rules to bring in more tax has limited chance of success without an effective collection system.
Tax Policy Making Principles
The day after the Spending Review the government published its Tax Policy Making Principles, laying out the principles that will guide how it will “design and deliver tax policy changes.”
Summarising its next steps, it pledged to develop tax policy in an “open and transparent way, with agile and frequent stakeholder engagement at the core of its approach.” It added this would enable them to deliver change quickly, while making sure the impacts of tax policy changes were fully understood.
My thoughts on the Tax Policy Making Principles
These principles would be brilliant for HMRC, taxpayers and tax advisers if they were achieved. It’s the utopia successive governments search for and, to date, none have achieved.
Our tax system is so complex it’s virtually impossible to make sure the impacts of tax policy changes are fully understood. There are few people who understand anything to do with tax policy outside of tax advisers and HMRC. So, how would it be possible for lay people to begin to understand the implications of proposals put forward that might seem of little relevance until the real impact of the changes becomes apparent.
I would welcome transparency in our industry but I’d also love to see simplification. However, despite many decades of successive governments attempting simplification, the rules are more complex than ever.
So, the cynic in me feels without significant changes to the whole system we’ll never achieve the Shangri-La of transparent and well-understood tax-policymaking.
UK tax gap now an estimated £46.8 billion
HMRC has released its latest figures for the difference between what tax is expected to be paid and what is actually paid.
The estimated tax gap for the 2023 to 2024 tax year is £46.8 billion – which means unpaid tax now stands at 5.3% of the total tax due.
And as is standard practice, previous years’ tax gap estimates have been amended, including the tax gap for the 2022 to 2023 tax year. This has been revised from 4.8% (£39.8 billion) to 5.6% (£46.4 billion).
Some of the key findings from this year’s figures show:
- Small businesses represent the largest proportion of the tax gap (60%)
- Corporation tax accounts for 40% of the total tax gap
- The main behavioural reasons for the overall tax gap include failure to take reasonable care (31%), error (15%) and evasion (14%)
As I wrote earlier in this blog, the Spending Review 2025 has pledged £1.7 billion to HMRC over four years to fund an extra 5,500 compliance and 2,400 debt management staff.
My thoughts on the tax gap figures
The tax gap is an interesting concept and there are different ways of defining what tax is expected to be paid versus what is actually paid.
One of the obvious questions has always been: if it is expected and not collected, then surely we should be concentrating on collecting more effectively?
That aside, it’s interesting the main ‘culprits’ are small businesses and corporation tax. There must surely be a correlation between mistakes that result in insufficient tax being paid and the cost-cutting that’s had to take place in recent years because of various factors that place more financial pressure on businesses.
With more emphasis on online filing and making it easier for businesses (and individuals) to file tax returns themselves, there will inevitably be errors in those returns. The tax system is incredibly difficult to navigate, even for specialists, so it’s no surprise lay people make mistakes when they submit returns without expert support.
These figures suggest there’s a real need for education in the business world or maybe assistance with relieving some of the financial pressure. Until this happens, it’s difficult to see how that tax gap will decrease as tax becomes more complex and more individuals and businesses make mistakes.




