Tax adviser David Hannah has been fined more than £40k and banned from the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) following a disciplinary hearing.

Hannah was found to have breached the ICAEW’s Code of Ethics by avoiding more than £30k of stamp duty land tax (SDLT) on a personal transaction.

Here, I examine the case and share my thoughts on the decision.

The allegations made against David Hannah

The ICAEW’s Tribunal Committee held a disciplinary hearing over the conduct of Hannah, a member of the professional membership organisation.

It was alleged that:

  1. Between 26 September 2011 and 12 October 2011, Mr David Warren Hannah ACA failed to disclose in any stamp duty land tax form the full consideration of £765,000 when directing payment and providing instructions to his solicitors for the purchase of the property ‘A’. In so doing, he avoided full assessment for SDLT and failed to comply with his obligations to pay £30,600 of SDLT on the transaction. This was in breach of the ICAEW’s Code of Ethics (Professional Behaviour) (effective from 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2019) because Hannah knew or should have known his actions may discredit the profession.
  2. Between 4 April 2022 and 26 July 2023, Hannah failed to notify the ICAEW’s Members’ Registrar of changes to his contact details within 28 days as required.
  3. From 15 June 2021 to 31 May 2023, Hannah failed to cooperate promptly and in full with the ICAEW’s Professional Conduct Department with its investigation into the complaint.

Brief background to the stamp duty land tax (SDLT) case

Throughout the time in question, Hannah held himself out as an experienced stamp duty land tax adviser who used an SDLT reduction arrangement to save £30,600 in SDLT on the purchase of his own property, property ‘A’, in 2011.

HMRC charged Hannah a penalty of £17,600 for what it alleged was a deliberate inaccuracy in the SDLT return and published Hannah’s details on its deliberate defaulters’ list.

Hannah appealed unsuccessfully against HMRC’s decision. He appealed initially to the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) in May 2019, and then to the Upper Tribunal in November 2020. And finally, the Court of Appeal refused to give Hannah permission to appeal in June 2021 on the grounds the case had no reasonable prospects of success.

HMRC told the ICAEW’s Professional Conduct Department (PCD) about Hannah’s defeated arrangements in December 2021. It was alleged Hannah had refused to provide his current contact details and stopped cooperating with PCD in April 2022.

Events after the Upper Tribunal ruling

The failure of Hannah’s appeals meant the £30,600 tax assessment issued jointly to Hannah and Mrs ‘C’, and the penalty issued to Hannah, stood and were enforceable by HMRC.

After the legal proceedings ended, Hannah’s case was the subject of several press articles in the spring of 2021, and he was named on HMRC’s deliberate defaulters’ list in March 2022.

The ICAEW’s Tribunal Committee decision

Hannah didn’t appear at the ICAEW’s Tribunal Committee hearing and wasn’t represented.

The tribunal was satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the facts of the first allegation had been proved and that the inaccuracies in the SDLT return submitted on 5 October 2011 were deliberate.

Regarding whether such conduct was in breach of the ICAEW’s Code of Ethics, the committee took the following into account:

  • Hannah held himself out as an expert in SDLT and had used his professional accreditation and knowledge even though this transaction related to him in a personal capacity.
  • He had persuaded Mr and Mrs R to participate in the scheme he’d devised when he knew they were financially vulnerable. It was clear from Mrs R’s email to her appointed solicitors and from her statement that Mr and Mrs R would have preferred to have sold their property to Hannah and his partner in the traditional way.
  • Mrs R had also made it clear she understood the reason for the transaction taking place in accordance with the scheme devised by Hannah was for Hannah’s own financial benefit by avoiding the payment of SDLT of £30,600.
  • Hannah had stipulated that solicitors of his choice would act on behalf of Mr and Mrs R in the sale.
  • Hannah had taken advice from leading counsel who described the scheme, as explained to him and being proposed by Hannah, as “extremely aggressive tax planning” and likely to be investigated.
  • In the event, the scheme implemented by Hannah, with particular reference to the annuity, differed to that on which leading counsel had advised.
  • The assessment of HMRC and the findings of the FTT and UT attracted adverse publicity.
  • In or about March 2022, Hannah was placed on the deliberate defaulters’ list and was required to pay a penalty of £17,136 (the tribunal noted the FTT cancelled Mrs ‘C’s penalty and ordered the full amount be paid by Hannah).
  • In reaching its decision, the tribunal also considered Hannah’s obligations under the Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation (PCRT).

The tribunal ruled Hannah’s conduct was in breach of the Code of Ethics in that he should have known his actions may discredit the profession.

Regarding allegation 2, the tribunal said this had been proved because it could see no proper reason for Hannah’s failure to notify the Members’ Registrar of the changes in his contact details in the period in question.

Finally, regarding the third allegation, the committee ruled Hannah’s failures to respond to ICAEW for certain periods of the time in question meant he was liable to disciplinary action.

The sentencing order

The tribunal excluded Hannah from membership of ICAEW, severely reprimanded him for his actions and ordered him to pay £40,231 in costs to ICAEW.

My thoughts on the David Hannah case – and advice for tax agents

This case is a reminder that the regulatory bodies won’t tolerate professionals using their knowledge for personal gain, particularly in a way that brings their character into question.

Gone are the days when people judged their advisers on how much tax they managed to dodge personally. This case reinforces the importance of maintaining a high standard of conduct in your personal life, otherwise it might impact on your business life.

Unfortunately, there are still advisers around who consider schemes appropriate whether or not they actually have any technical basis.

I’m sure this case was designed to send a message that tax professionals should approach paying tax in an appropriate way, whether in their personal affairs or when advising a client.

It’s another reminder we’re in a new age of tax planning and that reputation is just as important as technical knowledge.

Trusted UK tax advice

At Churchill Taxation we have many years’ experience helping people and businesses across the UK and worldwide to get their UK taxes right and safeguard their financial future.

Contact our team today

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation