An inheritance tax avoidance scheme that reduced an estate’s value by acquiring shares in a company and gifting those shares to an employee trust has been deemed “not a reasonable course of action”.

The General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) Advisory Panel issued their anonymous assessment after they were asked to give their opinion on the following three referrals:

  • Mrs Y (‘PR1’) as a personal representative of the late Mrs Z (‘the deceased’)
  • Mr W (‘PR2’), husband of PR1 and her fellow personal representative in relation to the deceased’s estate
  • X Ltd (‘trustee’), who acted as trustee to an employee trust created by a company incorporated by the deceased

The panel produced opinions for each of the three referrals, but the facts and circumstances were essentially the same.

What is the GAAR Advisory Panel?

The General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) Advisory Panel is an independent panel appointed by HMRC to consider, review, and (if appropriate) approve the tax body’s guidance relating to the GAAR. The panel’s remit also includes giving opinions on cases referred to it by HMRC.

Background to the IHT case

The case under scrutiny centred on the inheritance tax (IHT) applicable to the deceased’s estate.

A few months before her death, the deceased put a significant amount of money into a company she had set up. The company set up an employee trust and separately allocated shares to the deceased, which were gifted to the trust.

Gifts to employee trusts are in effect encouraged by Section 28 (s28) of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 (IHTA). So, if these arrangements were effective, the amount of IHT payable in relation to the deceased’s estate would be significantly reduced.

In its Opinion Notice, the panel said it wasn’t concerned with the various technical arguments between the parties in relation to s28. Instead, its focus was on considering the reasonableness of the arrangements, in accordance with the GAAR provisions in the Finance Act 2013 (FA13).

Case facts

Some of the facts about the case:

  • On 10 December 2015, the company was incorporated. PR1 became its sole director; the deceased subscribed for the single ordinary share issued. The advisers acted in relation to the company’s establishment.
  • At some point before 5 February 2016, the deceased transferred £995,341.58 into the company, reflected in a loan account.
  • Following a contact from the advisers, PR2 and D (daughter of PR2 and PR1) were appointed directors of the company on 9 February 2016, and the deceased was allotted shares in the company.
  • On 28 January 2016, the advisers wrote to the company about the establishment of a ‘succession trust’ by the company. Following a board meeting on 10 February 2016, the company resolved to establish the trust with an initial cash contribution from the company of £100. The trust was “…to be constituted as an employees’ share scheme…” with the purpose “…to allow the employees from time to time to share in the ownership of the group”.
  • In the following months, there were various transfers of shares, including a gift of 1,080,000 ordinary £1 shares by the deceased to the trust, the shares to be held by the trustee.
  • On 5 April 2016 the deceased made a will, appointing PR1 and PR2 as her trustees and executors. The deceased passed away on 3 June 2016. It appears that under her will she left 59,000 A ordinary £1 shares equally to PR1 and S (daughter of the deceased and sister to PR1).
  • The company accounts from incorporation to 31 March 2017 show that it held an investment property worth £900,000 and cash of £868,177. HMRC said the turnover reported was some £30,000, described as income from property. As far as the panel could tell, the company had no employees other than directors.

The GAAR Advisory Panel’s view on the IHT case

The panel commented that setting up a company, an employee trust and gifting shares to the trust for employee benefit were all reasonable steps. However, it said: “We have here a gift of the shares to a trust which (in effect) has no beneficiaries beyond the family. In addition, the family retains an influence on the funds as PR1 and PR2 are both directors of the company and the protectors of the trust.”

The panel accepted that future employees could benefit but within the timeframe before them there were no other employees, no real business (beyond the rental of the property) nor plans for setting in motion any expansion. It had no evidence that benefiting persons unknown, i.e. anyone who might happen to be an employee, was an aim of the deceased.

It added: “The net effect in reality – of allowing the family to benefit – does seem contrary to the aim of the legislation, as amplified by the Hansard debates to which we have referred.”

The panel said the arrangements in the case involved “abnormal steps designed to sidestep the restrictions on the s28 exemption and so reduce the intended IHT charge on the value of the deceased’s estate”.

It concluded that the entering into – and carrying out – of the tax arrangements were not reasonable courses of action in relation to the relevant tax provisions.

My thoughts on the inheritance tax case

The introduction of the GAAR Advisory Panel is a powerful addition to HMRC’s armoury.

At one time, advisers implemented planning based purely on the letter of the law. And unless there were targeted anti-avoidance rules in place, there was little HMRC could do to counter such planning.

But it’s important to always keep in mind that the GAAR now exists. And although it’s not routine for HMRC to refer matters to the GAAR’s Advisory Panel, it’s a route the tax body may take if it feels planning is artificial in nature, even though the planning might ‘tick all the boxes’ in terms of meeting the criteria in the legislation. This case is an example of this and is planning that has been in existence for many years.

There will, therefore, potentially be further consequences of this decision in terms of other taxpayers who have similar structures in place. If you or your client has such planning in place for IHT purposes, it would be wise to revisit it, in the light of the findings of the panel, to ensure your particular structure is robust and would withstand a challenge by HMRC.

Inheritance tax advice for trusts and estates

Our team of tax specialists are experienced at dealing with inheritance tax for trusts and estates.

Contact us today

Stephanie Churchill

Stephanie Churchill

Managing Director & Co-owner of Churchill Taxation